Water Purification Demonstration Project (Indirect Potable Reuse)
“IPR is usually defined as the augmentation of a drinking water source (surface water or groundwater) with recycled water, followed by an environmental buffer that precedes normal drinking water treatment” (from Regulatory Aspects of Direct Potable Reuse in California, by the National Water Research Institute).
The latest in a series of attempts by the City of San Diego to use purified reclaimed water to bolster its reservoir suppy is a feasibility test going by the name Water Purification Demonstration Project (originally called the Indirect Potable Reuse Reservoir Augmentation Demonstration Project).
IPR has been a controversial topic in San Diego’s quest for new water resources (historically, Mayor Sanders opposed and even vetoed the project in 2007 but the Council overrode him). Public support for IPR has been growing, though, and will likely continue growing.
During the one-year test, 1 million gallons per day (MGD) of IPR water are produced. Small amounts of that are analyzed in the lab, with the remaining water blended back in with the tertiary outflow for delivery to recycled water customers.
The goal, if the demonstration project is successful, is to produce 16 million gallons per day of IPR water. The water would be piped to the San Vicente Reservoir where it would be blended with raw imported water. It would be allowed to age for a period of time, at least six months. After that period, reservoir water would be sent for final treatment at the Alvarado Water Treatment Plant prior to distribution.
IPR is hardly without precedent. Almost never mentioned by local media news reports or critics is the fact that Las Vegas does it, and not with just a fraction of its wastewater as San Diego proposes to do. Virtually ALL wastewater from Las Vegas (plus all of Clark County and the city of Henderson…an average of 193 million gallons per day) receives this advanced treatment and goes into the Las Vegas Wash, which drains into Lake Mead (the city also gets credit for that return flow being counted as new water into the reservoir). As we know, Las Vegas also draws its drinking water supply from Lake Mead and it shouldn’t need mentioning that a large percentage of San Diego’s water comes through Lake Mead.
Singapore is well known for its large scale IPR project that produces “NEWater” (even in bottles!) to supplement its scant water supply.
A number of IPR proponents have formed an independent group, the Water Reliability Coalition, to organize an advocacy campaign for San Diego.
Immediately below are the latest news reports on the IPR project. Below that is a selected bibliography on IPR and related topics, which I will continue updating as I find new resources.
IPR Project news updates
- Jan 28, 2012: Monthly IPR project update Jan 2012
- Jan 24, 2012: Pure News No. 5
- Nov 1, 2011: Pure News No. 4
- Oct 19, 2011: Monthly IPR project update Oct 2011
- Sep 28, 2011: Monthly IPR project update Sep 2011
- Sep 27, 2011: Questions arise about the San Vicente Reservoir limnology study / GrokSurf
- Sep 14, 2011: San Diego Water Reliability Coalition launches website / GrokSurf
- Aug 3, 2011: Monthly IPR Project update Aug 2011
- Aug 3, 2011: Recycling water – a clear solution for San Diego? / SignOnSanDiego
- Jul 1, 2011: Advanced water purification facility begins operations for San Diego’s indirect potable reuse study (IPR) / GrokSurf
- Jun 30, 2011: Water Reliability Coalition Supports Water Purification Pilot Project
- May 31, 2011: Pure News No. 3
- May 11, 2011: Monthly IPR Project update May 2011
- Apr 13, 2011: Monthly IPR Project update April 2011
- Mar 30, 2011: Pure News No. 2
- Mar 1, 2011: Monthly IPR Project update Feb 2011
- Feb 28, 2011: February e-update on Water Purification Demonstration Project / San Diego Public Utilities Department
- Feb 1, 2011: Pure News No. 1 [Inaugural newsletter for the Water Purification Demonstration Project, Public Utilities Department]
- Jan 31, 2011: Monthly IPR Project update Jan 2011
- Dec 5, 2010: Monthly IPR Project update Nov 2010
- Oct 18, 2010: Monthly IPR Project update Oct 2010
- Oct 11, 2010: New source of drinking water hinges on pilot project / SignOnSanDiego
- Oct 5, 2010: Should San Diego ozonate its wastewater for IPR? / GrokSurf
- Sep 7, 2010: Monthly IPR Project update Sep 2010 / Public Utilities Dept
- Sep 2, 2010: San Diego’s IPR Coalition to change name; City continues neighborhood outreach / GrokSurf
- Aug 19, 2010: Updated fact sheet on San Diego’s Water Purification Demonstration Project / GrokSurf
- Jul 27, 2010: San Diego regional water news roundup: IPR special edition / GrokSurf
- Jul 27, 2010: Equinox Center releases new report on IPR water for San Diego; City Council approves new IPR facility / GrokSurf
- Jul 24, 2010: San Diego IPR Coalition sends message to City Council in support of water reuse project continuation / GrokSurf
- Jul 14, 2010: Monthly IPR project update July 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- Jul 12, 2010: Thinking about San Diego’s IPR water project / GrokSurf
- Jul 7, 2010: A primer/refresher on San Diego’s Water Purification Demonstration Project / GrokSurf
- Jun 16, 2010: San Diego’s IPR water treatment facility sidetracked by DeMaio and Lightner / GrokSurf
- Jun 13, 2010: Council committee to recommend contract for Indirect Potable Reuse facility / GrokSurf
- Jun 13, 2010: Monthly IPR project update June 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- May 16, 2010: San Diego lags on smart water policy / GrokSurf
- May 3, 2010: Monthly IPR project update May 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- Apr 26, 2010: I’ll take purified reclaimed water, thank you / GrokSurf
- Apr 14, 2010: Monthly IPR project update Apr 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- Apr 12, 2010: Water reclamation and sand mining would yield new water source for Helix District – but El Monte Valley residents voice concerns / East County Magazine
- Mar 17, 2010: Monthly IPR project update Mar 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- Feb 9, 2010: Monthly IPR project update Feb 2010 / Public Utilities Dept.
- Jan 27, 2010: San Diego recycled water project gets a boost from the city council / GrokSurf
- Jan 27, 2010: Coalition has hand in water recycling plan / SignOnSanDiego
- Jan 14, 2010: San Diego recycled water presentation at UCSD / GrokSurf
- Dec 14, 2009: Water reuse is imperative for a sustainable San Diego / GrokSurf
Selected bibliography (last updated: August 29, 2011)
- Aquifer Recharge (AR) and Aquifer Storage and Recovery (ASR) / EPA Office of Ground Water & Drinking Water
- Best Practices for Developing Indirect Potable Reuse Projects: Phase 1 Report / WateReuse Foundation
- California Ocean Wastewater Discharge Report and Inventory / Heal the Ocean
- City of San Diego Advanced Water Treatment Research Study Final Report Aug 2007
- City of San Diego response to Grand Jury Report “Water for the City of San Diego” dated March 25, 1999
- Comparison of water quality: City of San Diego vs. water agencies employing indirect potable reuse / San Diego County Taxpayers Association
- Direct potable reuse: a future imperative / Journal of Water Reuse and Desalination
- Direct potable reuse: a path forward / WateReuse Research Foundation
- Direct Potable Reuse Workshop / California Urban Water Agencies, National Water Research Institute, WateReuse California
- Dual plumbing code / California Department of Water Resources
- EPA guidelines for water reuse / U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (the closest the feds get to addressing indirect potable reuse)
- Evaluation of advanced water treatment for indirect potable reuse / Water Environment Foundation
- Final report of the May 11-12, 2009, Meeting of the Independent Advisory Panel for the City of San Diego Indirect Potable Reuse/Reservoir Augmentation (IPR/RA) Demonstration Project / National Water Research Institute
- Flushing away fears / Governing
- Framework for informed planning decisions regarding indirect potable reuse and dual pipe systems: Request For Proposal / WateReuse Foundation
- From the toilet to the tap / Boing Boing
- From toilet to tap: psychologists lend their expertise to overcoming the public’s aversion to reclaimed water / American Psychological Association
- Grand Jury Report “Water for the City of San Diego”
- How sewage gets recycled / Voice of San Diego
- Indirect potable reuse: a sustainable water supply alternative / Int J Environ Res Public Health
- Indirect potable reuse, San Diego tests advanced water treatment system / Proceedings of the Water Environment Federation
- Irvine Ranch Water District recycling plant video
- Issues in potable reuse: the viability of augmenting drinking water supplies with reclaimed water / National Research Council
- Mayor opposes ‘toilet-to-tap’ water supply proposal / Channel 10 News
- Mayor Sanders 2007 memorandum against use of IPR
- A Monstrous waste / San Diego Union-Tribune
- North City water reclamation plant
- Overcoming the stigma of ‘toilet-to-tap’ water / San Diego News Network
- Pharmaceuticals a problem for NF wastewater reuse / Desalination and Water Reuse
- Price of blue gold / Korea Times opinion
- Raw sewage to reclaimed water: the history of sewerage systems in the metropolitan San Diego-Tijuana region / Jon Jamieson
- Reclaimed water law is largely forgotten / San Diego Union-Tribune
- Recycled water pricing study draft report 2009 / San Diego Water Dept.
- Regulatory aspects of direct potable reuse in California / National Water Research Institute
- San Diego city attorney pushes for reclaimed water use / North County Times
- San Diego County Water Authority 2009 Public Opinion report
- San Diego County Water Authority water recycling page
- San Diego Formation aquifer storage and recovery study phase I / San Diego County Water Authority
- San Diego mulls turning sewage into drinking water / Fox News
- San Diego Water Department recycled water website
- San Diego Water Department Water Reuse website
- San Diego Water Reuse eUpdates archive 2004-2006
- San Diego’s water supply future / Building Industry Association of San Diego County
- Sanders wants to flush water reclamation plans / Voice of San Diego
- Senate Bill 918 (Pavley) to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for indirect potable water reuse
- Source, fate, and transport of endocrine disruptors, pharmaceuticals, and personal care products in drinking water sources in California / National Water Research Institute
- South Bay water reclamation plant
- Summary of costs and benefits of water supply alternatives / California Coastkeeper Alliance
- Using reclaimed water to augment potable water resources / Water Environment Federation, American Water Works Association
- Wastewater recycling can multiply greenhouse gas emissions / Physorg.com
- Wastewater to tapwater? / San Diego Union-Tribune
- Water Reuse Association San Diego chapter
- Water Reuse Study Final Draft Report March 2006 / San Diego Public Utilities Department
- Wholly H20: California’s Integrated Water Reuse Management Center
- Why cleaned wastewater stays dirty in our minds / NPR
- Wikipedia reclaimed water page
